RRI Live!

Listen to Radio Romania International Live

Alternative Romania

Alternative history, also called 'uchronia', has been imagined by many authors so far, generating a rich corpus of literature.

Alternative Romania
Alternative Romania

, 19.11.2018, 13:41

People often wonder what history would be like if it happened differently, what individuals, societies, and nations would be like. Alternative history, also called uchronia, has been imagined by many authors so far, generating a rich corpus of literature. The first to use the term uchronia was French writer and philosopher Charles Renouvier, who used it as the title of a book he published in 1876. Since then, countless such books have been written, depicting fictitious history.



The Romanian literary critic and comparative literature professor Virgil Nemoianu, who taught at several universities in the United States, undertook such an exercise in trying to imagine what Romania would have looked like if the union of 1918 had never taken place.



Here he is talking about it: “Reading all these historical novels, I eventually got to alternative history. This is based on events that never happened, and that are even absurd, such as the intervention of extraterrestrial beings into WWII. The popular fiction writer Harry Turtledove, for instance, wrote a novel called Ruled Britannia. In it, he imagines how things would have been had the Invincible Armada conquered England in 1588. As a result, Queen Elisabeth was imprisoned in the Tower of London, and England reverted to Catholicism. Lope de Vega was a young lieutenant who started hanging around Shakespeare to learn drama. However, in that world some politicians put together a revolt, which eventually prevailed. The writer has another novel, called The Two Georges, in which George III of Britain and George Washington reach an understanding, so that the US never breaks apart from the UK.”



1918 was the year when Greater Romania formed following the union of the Kingdom of Romania and Transylvania, Banat and Bukovina, a situation which is now taken for granted. Virgil Nemoianu doesnt believe that another course of history is absurd.



Here he is talking about it: “You can find, in the world and in Europe, plenty of different states that speak a single language. How would things stand if they had turned up otherwise? First of all, Romanians for 1000 years have been at the crossroads, with pressure from all sides, from imperial powers, from the east, south, and west. We had at least 3 kinds of pressure, 3 kinds of influence, modifying the way of being and morays in each of these countries. In the Old Kingdom there were French and Russian influences while on the other side of the Carpathians there was the German influence, in spite of the Hungarian dominance. How would these states have developed otherwise? I imagine that the transfer of people from one side of the Carpathians to the other would have been simple and fruitful. There was a transfer, of course. Even after Greater Romania was formed, there were reportedly opposite tendencies. On the one hand, there was this allurement of Central Europe, and on the other hand, that of the Balkan Confederation made up of countries Romania felt connected with, such as Yugoslavia, Bulgaria and Greece.”



Today’s Romania is made up of two different geo-cultural spaces, the extra-Carpathian space that was influenced by the Ottoman Empire and the Christian-Orthodox religion, and the central European space, where the influence of Hungary, of the Habsburg Monarchy and of Catholicism was dominant.



Starting from these realities, Virgil Nemoianu has built his alternative history of multiple Romania: “The internal nature of the two states would have been different. We can imagine that the trans-Carpathian area would have undergone more intense urbanization, would have probably had a center-left political orientation, as there was a well-rooted Social Democratic tradition there and a good financial network, with relatively small banks and emerging industries. This imaginary state could have been similar to what Slovakia, Slovenia and Croatia are today. The Old Kingdom would have been probably stronger, from an intellectual point of view, because there were very good universities with a solid intellectual tradition and could have had a very advanced agriculture. It could have looked southwards, towards the Balkans, with much more confidence. From a religious point of view, in the imaginary trans-Carpathian state there was a certain kind of cooperation between Orthodox and Greek-Catholic believers, but there were conflicts as well as and friendships. The Old Kingdom was purer from an Orthodox point of view, therefore closer to the Balkans and the East. I also believe that a far right group would have been set up in a different way. Of course, there would have been disadvantages. The unified Romania had a certain economic weight in the inter-war period, even in the Communist period. From an intellectual and cultural point of view, we can speak of cooperation and contacts between the two sides of the Carpathians. I don’t mean to imply that it would have been better if the two sides had been separated, if there had been two Romanian states. What I mean is that there would have been good things as well as bad things. That is why I have imagined a multiple Romania.”



History happened as we know it today, because it was the best formula that people could find at the time. Uchronia does nothing but imagine scenarios and is nothing but a literary game. Multiple Romania or alternative Romania is based on different views on the world, which we can also see today, but it is a version that does not offer credibility.

Giuseppe Mazzini and the Romanians
The History Show Monday, 11 November 2024

Giuseppe Mazzini and the Romanians

The Romanian political elites of 1848 were influenced by the ideas of the Italian Giuseppe...

Giuseppe Mazzini and the Romanians
banner-Pro-Memoria.-960x540-1.jpg
The History Show Monday, 04 November 2024

The Spark(Scanteia) communist newspaper

The press was one of the communist regime’s most powerful weapons regarding propaganda. The freedom of expression and of the press was a right that...

The Spark(Scanteia) communist newspaper
RRI
The History Show Monday, 28 October 2024

Securitate and the KGB parting ways

The most feared institution of the Romanian communist state was the political police known as Securitate, created on the model of the NKVD, which...

Securitate and the KGB parting ways
Vasile Luca
The History Show Monday, 21 October 2024

Vasile Luca

From the end of World War II in 1945 until 1989, the Red Army imposed communist party regimes in the countries of Central and Eastern Europe. They...

Vasile Luca
The History Show Monday, 14 October 2024

The Romanian Communist Party and the Agrarian Reform

According to the Marxist-Leninist theses about means of production, property had to be common, owned by all those who used it and created added...

The Romanian Communist Party and the Agrarian Reform
The History Show Monday, 07 October 2024

The Romanian military fleet in WWII

The history of the Romanian military fleet begins in the middle of the 19th century, when, after the union of the two principalities of Moldova and...

The Romanian military fleet in WWII
The History Show Monday, 30 September 2024

Ana Pauker

Ana Pauker is one of the most conspicuous figureheads in the history of the communist regime in Romania. Ana Pauker played a crucial part in the team...

Ana Pauker
The History Show Monday, 23 September 2024

Nicolae Titulescu and the Romanian diplomacy in Europe in the 1930s

  The diplomacies of countries that gravitate around the powerful ones, always have the mission of being one step ahead of events. They must...

Nicolae Titulescu and the Romanian diplomacy in Europe in the 1930s

Partners

Muzeul Național al Țăranului Român Muzeul Național al Țăranului Român
Liga Studentilor Romani din Strainatate - LSRS Liga Studentilor Romani din Strainatate - LSRS
Modernism | The Leading Romanian Art Magazine Online Modernism | The Leading Romanian Art Magazine Online
Institului European din România Institului European din România
Institutul Francez din România – Bucureşti Institutul Francez din România – Bucureşti
Muzeul Național de Artă al României Muzeul Național de Artă al României
Le petit Journal Le petit Journal
Radio Prague International Radio Prague International
Muzeul Național de Istorie a României Muzeul Național de Istorie a României
ARCUB ARCUB
Radio Canada International Radio Canada International
Muzeul Național al Satului „Dimitrie Gusti” Muzeul Național al Satului „Dimitrie Gusti”
SWI swissinfo.ch SWI swissinfo.ch
UBB Radio ONLINE UBB Radio ONLINE
Strona główna - English Section - polskieradio.pl Strona główna - English Section - polskieradio.pl
creart - Centrul de Creație Artă și Tradiție al Municipiului Bucuresti creart - Centrul de Creație Artă și Tradiție al Municipiului Bucuresti
italradio italradio
Institutul Confucius Institutul Confucius
BUCPRESS - știri din Cernăuți BUCPRESS - știri din Cernăuți

Affiliates

Euranet Plus Euranet Plus
AIB | the trade association for international broadcasters AIB | the trade association for international broadcasters
Digital Radio Mondiale Digital Radio Mondiale
News and current affairs from Germany and around the world News and current affairs from Germany and around the world
Comunità radiotelevisiva italofona Comunità radiotelevisiva italofona

Providers

RADIOCOM RADIOCOM
Zeno Media - The Everything Audio Company Zeno Media - The Everything Audio Company